Connect Mailchimp

Updated Oct 26, 2026 · 5 min read · Pro, Business and Agency plans

This article shows you how to create a Mailchimp API key, connect Mailchimp to PlayerMagick, and send the emails a gate collects to a Mailchimp audience with tags.

Available on: Pro, Business and Agency plans.

Before you start

  • You need a Mailchimp account and permission to create API keys in it.
  • Only the PlayerMagick account owner or an admin can connect Mailchimp. See Understand team roles.

Mailchimp sometimes renames its menus. If a label below does not match exactly, look for the closest one.

Step 1: Create an API key in Mailchimp

  1. Log in to Mailchimp.
  2. Click your profile icon and choose Profile.
  3. Open Extras and choose API keys.
  4. Click Create A Key and name it PlayerMagick.
  5. Copy the whole key. Mailchimp may show it only once.

A Mailchimp key ends with a dash and your account's datacenter, for example -us21. Copy that part too: it tells PlayerMagick where your account lives, so there is no separate field for it.

Step 2: Connect Mailchimp in PlayerMagick

  1. Go to Settings → Integrations.
  2. Click Connect an email tool (or Connect next to Mailchimp) and choose Mailchimp.
  3. Paste the key into API key.
  4. Click Test and connect.

PlayerMagick checks the key with Mailchimp and reads one of your audiences before saving it. The card then shows "Mailchimp · " and your Mailchimp account's name, with "Connected".

Step 3: Choose an audience and tags for a gate

  1. Open your video, click the Interactions tab and click the email gate.
  2. Under Send leads to, choose your Mailchimp account in Email tool.
  3. In Audience, choose the audience.
  4. Add up to 5 Tags (optional). Mailchimp creates tags that do not exist yet.
  5. Leave Ask people to confirm their email (double opt-in) on, or turn it off (see below).
  6. Click Save destination.

All the other options (sending existing leads, pausing, statuses): Send your leads to your email tool.

Confirmation emails in Mailchimp

For Mailchimp, you choose per gate. Ask people to confirm their email (double opt-in) is on by default.

  • On: Mailchimp sends its confirmation email to each new contact. They join your audience as subscribed once they click it; until then Mailchimp shows them as pending.
  • Off: new contacts are subscribed at once, without a confirmation email.

We recommend keeping it on. Anyone can type an address in a gate, including someone else's, and confirmed contacts protect your sender reputation with Mailchimp. The confirmation email is Mailchimp's, with your audience's settings and design.

The choice applies only to people who are new to the audience. Someone already in it keeps their status, and someone waiting to confirm does not get a second confirmation email.

Good to know

  • Someone already in the audience stays as they are (status, name and other fields). Only your tags are added. Leads shows "Sent" with "Already on the list; tags added."
  • Someone who unsubscribed or was cleaned in that audience is never subscribed again and gets no tags. Leads shows Not added: "this person unsubscribed in Mailchimp before."
  • Someone you permanently deleted in Mailchimp cannot be added back by any app. Leads shows Not added: "this person was permanently removed from Mailchimp and can't be added through the API." They can rejoin through your Mailchimp signup form.
  • Addresses Mailchimp thinks are fake or invalid are refused: Not added, "Mailchimp refused this address as invalid."
  • Speed: thousands of sign-ups reach Mailchimp within minutes.
  • Several Mailchimp accounts: you can connect more than one (for example, for clients). The same Mailchimp account cannot be connected twice.
  • Automations: once Mailchimp is connected, add ?pm_mc=*|UNIQID|* to your email links so automations can tag the subscribers who watch; see Recognise viewers from your emails.

Error messages

MessageWhat to do
"Copy the whole key, including the part after the dash (for example -us21)."The end of the key is missing or changed. Copy the whole key again from Mailchimp.
"Mailchimp did not accept this key. Check that you copied the whole key."The key is wrong, was deleted in Mailchimp, or its ending (like -us21) does not match your account. Copy it again or create a new one.
"Paste the API key from Mailchimp."The field is empty, or the key has spaces or line breaks in the middle. Paste it again.
"Mailchimp didn't answer. Try again in a minute."Mailchimp did not answer within 10 seconds. Try again in a minute.
"Mailchimp asked us to slow down. Try again in a minute."Mailchimp received too many requests for this key. Wait a minute.
"This key can't read your lists. Use a key of a user who can manage contacts."The key cannot read your audiences. Create a key as a Mailchimp user who can manage audiences.
"This Mailchimp account is already connected. Use Replace key on its card to change the key."This Mailchimp account is already in Settings → Integrations.

After Mailchimp is connected:

  • The card shows "Key not working": the key was deleted or disabled in Mailchimp. Create a new key and click Replace key on the card. See Key not working.
  • A gate says the audience "no longer exists in Mailchimp": choose another audience. See List no longer exists.
  • Replace key warns "This key is for another Mailchimp account": the new key belongs to a different Mailchimp account. If you click Use this key, gates that send to the old account's audiences stop until you choose an audience of the new account.

All statuses and fixes: Fix an email tool error.

Limits

  • PlayerMagick connects with an API key only; there is no "Sign in with Mailchimp" button yet.
  • Only the email address, the audience, your tags and the double opt-in choice are sent: no first name or merge fields.

Was this article helpful?