Fix an email tool error
This article explains every status and message you can see when PlayerMagick sends your leads to Kit, Mailchimp, ActiveCampaign or GetResponse, and what to do about each one.
Available on: Pro, Business and Agency plans.
In the examples below, Mailchimp and "Main list" stand for your own email tool and list.
Where to find the reason
- Leads: the Email tool column shows each lead's status. Hover over (or tap) it to read the reason, for example "Paused: Mailchimp refused the key." Use the Email tool status menu to show only Failed or Paused leads.
- The gate in the editor: under Send leads to, a notice explains a problem with that gate's email tool or list, with the last 7 days ("Last 7 days: 412 sent · 3 failed · 0 waiting").
- Settings → Integrations: each email tool's card shows its state next to its name, for example "Connected" or "Key not working", with an explanation.
- Your inbox: the owner and admins get an email when sending stops. See Emails PlayerMagick sends you.
Your gates keep collecting emails whatever the problem: every lead stays in Leads, and paused emails are sent once the problem is fixed (within 30 days).
Statuses at a glance
| What you see | Meaning | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Sent | Your email tool accepted the contact. | Nothing. |
| Waiting | On its way, or waiting for the next try. | Nothing. See Waiting. |
| Paused | Something must be fixed first. | Read the reason and fix it: see the sections below. |
| Not added | Your email tool refused it, or the person unsubscribed before. Final. | Usually nothing. See Not added. |
| Failed | No answer after 6 tries, or waited 30 days. | Fix the cause, then Retry sending. See Failed. |
| — | The gate had no email tool when this lead arrived. | Use Send existing leads to send it. |
| Card state in Settings → Integrations | Section |
|---|---|
| "Connected" | Everything works. |
| "Key not working" | Key not working |
| "Not answering" | Not answering |
| "Contact limit reached" | Contact limit reached |
| "Disconnected" | Disconnected |
| "Paused: needs Pro" | Paused: needs Pro |
| "Account suspended" | Account suspended |
Key not working
You see: the card shows "Key not working" and "Mailchimp refused the key. Replace the key to start sending again." (editors see "Ask an owner or admin to replace the key."). In Leads: Paused, "Paused: Mailchimp refused the key." The owner and admins get the email "Mailchimp refused your API key".
Why: the key was deleted, reset or disabled in your email tool, or the person it belongs to lost access. PlayerMagick checks once more before showing this, so a one-off hiccup does not pause your sending.
Fix (owner or admin):
- Create a new key in your email tool: Kit, Mailchimp, ActiveCampaign, GetResponse.
- In Settings → Integrations, click Replace key on the card.
- Paste the new key and click Test and save. If the test fails, the old key stays and nothing changes.
You see "New key saved for Mailchimp · Spring Studio. Waiting emails are sent within a minute." If you fixed the problem in your email tool instead (for example, you gave the user their permissions back), click Test again: "The key works. Mailchimp is connected." also starts sending again.
If Replace key says "This key is for another Mailchimp account", you pasted a key of a different account. Click Cancel and use a key of the same account, or Use this key if you really want to switch: gates then need a list of the new account.
Not answering
You see: the card shows "Not answering" and "Mailchimp isn't answering. Emails wait and are sent when it's back." In Leads: Waiting, with the same sentence. The owner and admins get the email "Mailchimp isn't answering".
Why: your email tool did not answer 5 times in a row: it may be down or in maintenance.
Fix: nothing to do. PlayerMagick checks it every 5 minutes and sends everything waiting, oldest first, as soon as it answers. No tries are used up in the meantime. If it lasts more than a day, check your email tool's status page. For ActiveCampaign, also check that the API URL on the card is still your account's URL.
List no longer exists
You see: the gate says "Main list no longer exists in Mailchimp. Choose another audience to send the 1 waiting email." The card says "Gates that send to 1 of its lists need a list chosen again: the list no longer exists in Mailchimp, or the key now belongs to another Mailchimp account. Choose one in each gate's "Send leads to"." In Leads: Paused, "Paused: Main list no longer exists in Mailchimp, or Mailchimp now uses another account's key. Choose a list again in the gate's Send leads to." The owner and admins get the email ""Main list" no longer exists in Mailchimp".
Why: the list, audience or form was deleted in your email tool (or, in Kit, the form is no longer active). Other gates sending to other lists keep working.
After a key of another account: if an owner or admin used Replace key with a key of a different account (and confirmed with Use this key), the gate says "Mailchimp now uses the key of another account. Choose an audience of that account to send the 3 waiting emails." Lists are numbered differently in every account, so PlayerMagick sends nothing to the new account until you choose a list there, gate by gate. No email is sent about it.
Fix (editor or above), for each gate that sends to it:
- Open the video, click the Interactions tab and click the gate.
- Under Send leads to, click Change.
- Choose another list. If it is new, click Reload from Mailchimp first.
- Click Save destination.
The waiting emails go to the new list within a minute.
Contact limit reached
You see: the card shows "Contact limit reached" and "Mailchimp says your plan's contact limit is reached. Emails wait here." In Leads: Paused, "Paused: Mailchimp says your plan's contact limit is reached." The owner and admins get the email "Mailchimp: your plan's contact limit is reached".
Why: your plan with the email tool is full and it accepts no more contacts. GetResponse and Kit say so when a contact is added, so PlayerMagick shows this state for them. Mailchimp and ActiveCampaign keep accepting contacts over a plan's limit (they bill the extra contacts or stop your campaigns instead), so for them this state does not appear: check your plan in the email tool itself.
Fix: make room in your email tool (remove contacts you no longer need) or upgrade your plan there. Then an owner or admin clicks Test again on the card. Waiting emails are sent within a minute.
Disconnected
You see: the card shows "Disconnected" and "Emails for it wait here for up to 30 days. To send them, connect the same Mailchimp account again." The gate says "Mailchimp is disconnected. Emails wait here until you connect it again." In Leads: Paused, "Paused: Mailchimp is disconnected."
Why: someone clicked Disconnect on the card.
Fix: an owner or admin clicks Connect again on the card and pastes a key of the same account: "… is connected again. Its gates and waiting emails continue." To use another account instead, connect it, then choose it in each gate's Send leads to: the waiting emails move to it.
A disconnected email tool is removed 30 days after it was disconnected.
Email tool removed
You see: the gate says "This email tool was removed. Choose another one; new emails wait until you do."
Why: the email tool was disconnected more than 30 days ago and removed.
Fix: under Send leads to, click Change, choose another email tool and list, and save. New leads collected in the meantime wait as Paused ("Paused: this email tool was removed. Choose another one in the gate's Send leads to.") and go to the new email tool when you save. Emails that were waiting before the removal are not sent; send those with Send existing leads. Leads that wait more than 30 days become Failed.
Paused: needs Pro
You see: the cards show "Paused: needs Pro". In Leads: Paused, "Paused: email tools need the Pro or Agency plan."
Why: your account is on Starter, for example after a Pro subscription ended and the account went back to its Starter lifetime plan. Your keys stay saved.
Fix: upgrade to Pro, Business or Agency within 30 days; waiting emails are then sent within about a minute. See Upgrade your plan.
Account suspended
You see: the cards show "Account suspended". In Leads: Paused, "Paused: the account is suspended."
Fix: once the account is active again, sending continues by itself. Email support at support@playermagick.com. See Refunds and what happens to your account.
Paused by you
You see: the gate says "Sending is paused. New emails are kept here and not sent until you resume." In Leads: Paused, "Paused by you: sending is paused on this gate. Resume it in the video's Interactions."
Why: someone on your team clicked Pause sending on that gate.
Fix: if you want to send them, open the gate and click Resume. Delete any fake leads in Leads first: deleted leads are never sent. To drop them instead, click Cancel waiting emails. See Pause sending and resume.
Paused after a spike of sign-ups
You see: the gate says "We paused sending to protect your email account. Check the recent leads, then Resume." In Leads: Paused, "Paused after a spike of sign-ups, to protect your email account. Check the recent leads, then Resume in the video's Interactions." The owner and admins get the email "We paused sending to Mailchimp after a spike of sign-ups".
Why: your gates collected far more new addresses in an hour than usual: more than 1,000 for an email tool that adds people without a confirmation email (ActiveCampaign, Kit with No form, tags only, Mailchimp with double opt-in off), or more than 10,000 for any email tool. A flood of addresses that are not the people's own can get your email account suspended, so PlayerMagick pauses those gates by itself. The gates keep collecting emails.
Fix (editor or above):
- In Leads, look at the most recent leads of that video. Delete the ones that look fake: deleted leads are never sent.
- Open the gate and click Resume if the rest are real (a webinar, a launch). They are sent within a minute, and the same hour's sign-ups do not pause the gate again.
- Or click Cancel waiting emails to send none of them: they stay in Leads as Not added.
Waiting
Waiting needs nothing from you. The reason tells you what is going on:
| Reason | Meaning |
|---|---|
| "Waiting to be sent to Mailchimp · Main list." | It is on its way. |
| "Mailchimp didn't answer. Next try at 11:06." | The last try failed. PlayerMagick tries again after 1 minute, 5 minutes, 30 minutes, 2 hours and 12 hours. |
| "Unexpected answer from Mailchimp. Next try at 11:06." | Your email tool gave an answer PlayerMagick could not use. It tries again on the same schedule. |
| "Mailchimp asked us to slow down. Next try at 11:06." | Your email tool received many requests (for example, during a launch). It is sent as soon as allowed, without using a try. |
| "Mailchimp isn't answering. Emails wait and are sent when it's back." | See Not answering. |
Not added
Not added is final: PlayerMagick does not try again.
| Reason | What to do |
|---|---|
| "Not added: Mailchimp refused this address as invalid." | The address has a typo, does not exist, or looks fake to your email tool. Nothing to do. |
| "Not added: this person unsubscribed in Mailchimp before." | The person unsubscribed from that list before (or bounced, or was cleaned or blocked), so PlayerMagick does not add them again or tag them. If they want back in, they can use your email tool's own signup form. See People who unsubscribed are never added again. |
| "Not added: this person was permanently removed from Mailchimp and can't be added through the API." | Mailchimp only: you deleted this person permanently in Mailchimp. Only Mailchimp's own signup form can add them back. |
| "Not added: Mailchimp refused this address." | Your email tool refused this one address, for example Mailchimp's protection against an address signed up to many lists in a short time. Nothing to do. |
| "Not sent: its gate or video was removed before it was sent." | The gate was deleted, or its video was deleted, while the email was waiting. It is not sent, and restoring the video does not send it. |
| "Not sent: the waiting emails were cancelled." | Someone clicked Cancel waiting emails. |
| "Not added: Mailchimp refused this contact." | Your email tool refused it for another reason. If many leads show this, email support. |
Retry sending is not offered for these.
Failed
| Reason | What to do |
|---|---|
| "Failed after 6 tries: Mailchimp didn't answer." | Your email tool did not answer for about 14 and a half hours. Check that it works, then retry. |
| "Failed: waited 30 days while sending was paused. Retry once the cause is fixed." | Sending was paused for 30 days (for example, a key not working, a missing list, Starter, disconnected). Fix the cause, then retry. |
To retry: in Leads, open the row's menu (…) and click Retry sending, or tick several leads and click Retry failed (3). In the gate's Send leads to, Retry failed (12) retries every failed lead of that video. See Retry failed emails.
Sent with a note
| Note | Meaning |
|---|---|
| "Already on the list; tags added." | The person was already on your list. Their status and details are unchanged; your tags were added. |
| "Accepted by GetResponse. It may take a few minutes to appear there." | GetResponse adds contacts a few moments after accepting them. With confirmation on, they appear after confirming. |
| "A tag could not be added." | The contact was added, but your email tool refused one of the tags. Check the tag's name, or your email tool's limits on tags. |
Errors when you connect or replace a key
These appear in the Connect or Replace key dialog. Nothing is saved when the test fails, and with Replace key the old key keeps working.
| Message | What to do |
|---|---|
| "Mailchimp did not accept this key. Check that you copied the whole key." | Copy the key again, or create a new one. |
| "Paste the API key from Mailchimp." | The field is empty, or the key has spaces or line breaks in the middle. |
| "Copy the whole key, including the part after the dash (for example -us21)." | Mailchimp only. See Connect Mailchimp. |
| "This looks like an older Kit key (v3). In Kit, go to Settings → Developer and create a v4 API key." | Kit only. See Connect Kit. |
| "Use the API URL from Settings → Developer, ending in .api-us1.com or .activehosted.com." | ActiveCampaign only. See Connect ActiveCampaign. |
| "This key can't read your lists. Use a key of a user who can manage contacts." | The key works but cannot read lists. Use a key of a user with more permissions. |
| "Mailchimp didn't answer. Try again in a minute." | Your email tool did not answer within 10 seconds. |
| "Mailchimp asked us to slow down. Try again in a minute." | Wait a minute. |
| "This Mailchimp account is already connected. Use Replace key on its card to change the key." | The account is already in Settings → Integrations. |
| "You can connect up to 10 email tools." | Disconnect one you no longer use first. |
| "Too many key tests in the last few minutes. Try again in a few minutes." | You can test about 10 keys in 10 minutes. Wait a few minutes. |
| "Only owners and admins can connect email tools." | Ask an owner or admin. |
| "Send leads to your email tool on Pro, Business and Agency." | Your account is on Starter. See Upgrade your plan. |
| "This account is suspended, so email tools can't be changed." | See Account suspended. |
| "Email tool connections are not available right now. Try again later." | A problem on our side. Try again later, or email support. |
| "PlayerMagick could not finish the test. Try again in a moment." | Try again. If it keeps happening, email support. |
Errors when you choose a list or tags
| Message | What to do |
|---|---|
| "Couldn't load your lists from Mailchimp. Try again." | Your email tool did not answer. Click Reload from Mailchimp. |
| "Mailchimp asked us to slow down. Try again in a minute." | Your email tool received many requests. Wait a minute, then reload. |
| "This account is suspended, so lists can't be loaded." | See Account suspended. |
| "Sending leads to an email tool needs the Pro or Agency plan." | See Paused: needs Pro. |
| "This audience no longer exists in Mailchimp. Reload the lists and choose another." | The list was deleted while you were choosing. Reload and choose another. |
| "Check the tags: up to 5, each up to 50 characters, without commas." | Shorten or remove tags. |
| "Up to 5 tags." / "A tag can be at most 50 characters." / "A tag can't contain a comma." | As it says. |
| "Your role can't change where a gate sends its emails." | Viewers cannot. Ask an editor, admin or owner. |
| "Existing emails of this email tool are still being sent. Try again when they're done." | Another Send existing leads to the same email tool is still running. |
| "You did this several times in the last few minutes. Try again in a few minutes." | Wait a few minutes. |
Still stuck?
Email support at support@playermagick.com with the email tool, the name of its card, the video, and a screenshot of the message. Never send your API key, to us or anyone else. Support can see each email tool's state and counts, but never your key or your leads' addresses.